Comparisons / Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract vs Man Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit

Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract vs Man Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit

**Verdict: Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract is the clear winner** Nutrabay scores 9.5/10 versus Man Matters' 6.3/10 — a significant 3.2-point gap driven by superior formulation and dosing. The core difference: Nutrabay delivers 600mg of ashwagandha per serving, which aligns with clinically studied doses (300-600mg). Man Matters provides only 100mg ashwagandha — just 17% of Nutrabay's amount — despite ashwagandha being the primary ingredient in its name. Nutrabay achieves perfect 10.0 scores in Formula, Dosing, and Transparency with its single-ingredient, research-backed approach. Man Matters' multi-ingredient blend (including 250mg Gokshura, 200mg Shilajit, 150mg Safed Musli) scores poorly on Formula (5.8) and Dosing (5.4) because the ashwagandha content is sub-therapeutic. The value gap is stark: Nutrabay costs ₹6.63 per serving while Man Matters costs ₹13.32 — exactly double the price for significantly less active ingredient. Nutrabay scores 7.6 for Value versus Man Matters' 4.6. **Choose Nutrabay** if you want effective ashwagandha supplementation at half the cost. Choose Man Matters only if you specifically want the additional Ayurvedic ingredients, understanding you're getting minimal ashwagandha.

Quick Verdict

**Verdict: Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract is the clear winner** Nutrabay scores 9.5/10 versus Man Matters' 6.3/10 — a significant 3.2-point gap driven by superior formulation and dosing. The core difference: Nutrabay delivers 600mg of ashwagandha per serving, which aligns with clinically studied doses (300-600mg). Man Matters provides only 100mg ashwagandha — just 17% of Nutrabay's amount — despite ashwagandha being the primary ingredient in its name. Nutrabay achieves perfect 10.0 scores in Formula, Dosing, and Transparency with its single-ingredient, research-backed approach. Man Matters' multi-ingredient blend (including 250mg Gokshura, 200mg Shilajit, 150mg Safed Musli) scores poorly on Formula (5.8) and Dosing (5.4) because the ashwagandha content is sub-therapeutic. The value gap is stark: Nutrabay costs ₹6.63 per serving while Man Matters costs ₹13.32 — exactly double the price for significantly less active ingredient. Nutrabay scores 7.6 for Value versus Man Matters' 4.6. **Choose Nutrabay** if you want effective ashwagandha supplementation at half the cost. Choose Man Matters only if you specifically want the additional Ayurvedic ingredients, understanding you're getting minimal ashwagandha.

Overall winner: Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha ExtractNutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract is the overall winner by score (9.5 vs 7.1).

Product Cards

Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract

Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract

Nutrabay

9.5/10

Highly RecommendedWinner

Cost/serving: ₹6.63

Based on MRP. Actual price may be lower.

Form: Capsule

Servings: 30

Nutrabay Ashwagandha KSM-66 scores an impressive 9.1/10 and is highly recommended for its well-dosed and affordable formulation, delivering effective results at just ₹7.48 per serving. While it lacks third-party testing, the product's transparency regarding ingredient disclosure and use of clinically-supported KSM-66 assures consumers of its quality.

Read full review →Buy on Amazon →
Man Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit

Man Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit

Man Matters

7.1/10

RecommendedRunner-up

Cost/serving: ₹4.33

Based on MRP. Actual price may be lower.

Form: Capsule

Servings: 60

Man Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit is a budget-friendly adaptogen supplement with excellent transparency and good value. Dosing improvements could enhance its efficacy.

Read full review →Buy on Amazon →

Head-to-Head Metrics

Scroll right to compare all products →

MetricNutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha ExtractMan Matters Ashwagandha + ShilajitWinner
Overall✓ 9.57.1Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract
Formula✓ 10.05.8Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract
Dosing✓ 10.05.4Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract
Value7.6✓ 8.6Man Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit
Transparency✓ 10.0✓ 10.0Tie
Cost/Serving₹6.63✓ ₹4.33Man Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit

Key Differences

• Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract costs ₹6.63 per serving vs Man Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit at ₹4.33 — Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract is 53% more expensive (Man Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit is 53% cheaper).

• Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract MRP: ₹199 for 30 servings vs Man Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit MRP: ₹494 for 60 servings.

• Formula: Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract scores 10.0 vs Man Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit's 5.8 — Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract has a stronger ingredient formula.

• Dosing: Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract scores 10.0 vs Man Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit's 5.4 — Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract hits clinical dose benchmarks more accurately.

• Value: Man Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit scores 8.6 vs Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract's 7.6 — Man Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit offers better value per serving.

Ingredient Comparison

Shared ingredientNutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha ExtractMan Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit
Ashwagandha600 mg100 mg

Only in Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract

  • None detected.

Only in Man Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit

  • Gokshura
  • Shilajit
  • Safed Musli
  • Kaunchbeej
  • Saffron

Buy Nutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha Extract if:

  • You want the stronger overall performer.
  • Ingredient quality is your top priority.

Buy Man Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit if:

  • You want the most affordable option.
  • You want more servings per pack.

Price Comparison

MetricNutrabay Wellness Ashwagandha ExtractMan Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit
MRP₹199₹494
Cost/Serving₹6.63₹4.33

Based on MRP. Actual price may be lower.

Servings/Pack3060

Explore alternatives

Compare more products in this category from the full ranking hub.

Best Adaptogens

Research Sources

Related Comparisons

Other head-to-head matchups featuring these products

Carbamide Forte Ashwagandha KSM-66 600mg vs Man Matters Ashwagandha + ShilajitMan Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit vs Himalaya AshvagandhaMan Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit vs Wellbeing Nutrition AshwagandhaNOW Foods Ashwagandha 450mg vs Man Matters Ashwagandha + Shilajit

Related Guides

Ashwagandha Side Effects: Safe Use Guide (2026)

Ashwagandha is widely used across India for stress and energy, but side effects are real and often underreported. This guide breaks down who should be cautious, what the evidence actually shows, and how to use standardized extracts safely without overstating benefits or ignoring risks.

Adaptogens

3 min read · Last updated: 8 Mar 2026