Comparisons / AS-IT-IS Nutrition Whey Protein Concentrate vs Nutrabay Pure 100% Whey Protein Concentrate
**Verdict: AS-IT-IS Nutrition Whey Protein Concentrate wins by a narrow margin** AS-IT-IS scores 6.0/10 versus Nutrabay's 5.9/10, making them nearly comparable, but AS-IT-IS edges ahead on value and formula strength. The critical difference lies in **formula quality** (7.5 vs 2.8) and **price efficiency**. AS-IT-IS costs ₹161.52 per serving compared to Nutrabay's ₹195.37—that's ₹33.85 cheaper per serving, translating to roughly ₹1,015 monthly savings for daily users. This superior value score (8.6 vs 6.5) reflects genuine cost advantage. However, Nutrabay provides complete nutritional transparency with 72.22g protein per serving, probiotic blend (138.89 CFU), and digestive enzymes (416.67mg)—features AS-IT-IS doesn't detail beyond 21g BCAAs. Nutrabay also scores 6.0 on dosing versus AS-IT-IS's concerning 0.0, suggesting AS-IT-IS may have inadequate serving size information. **Choose AS-IT-IS** if you prioritize budget and trust the brand despite limited nutritional breakdown. **Choose Nutrabay** if you want complete ingredient visibility, digestive support, and don't mind paying 21% more per serving. Both offer perfect transparency scores (10.0), but AS-IT-IS delivers better bang-for-buck for cost-conscious buyers.
Quick Verdict
**Verdict: AS-IT-IS Nutrition Whey Protein Concentrate wins by a narrow margin** AS-IT-IS scores 6.0/10 versus Nutrabay's 5.9/10, making them nearly comparable, but AS-IT-IS edges ahead on value and formula strength. The critical difference lies in **formula quality** (7.5 vs 2.8) and **price efficiency**. AS-IT-IS costs ₹161.52 per serving compared to Nutrabay's ₹195.37—that's ₹33.85 cheaper per serving, translating to roughly ₹1,015 monthly savings for daily users. This superior value score (8.6 vs 6.5) reflects genuine cost advantage. However, Nutrabay provides complete nutritional transparency with 72.22g protein per serving, probiotic blend (138.89 CFU), and digestive enzymes (416.67mg)—features AS-IT-IS doesn't detail beyond 21g BCAAs. Nutrabay also scores 6.0 on dosing versus AS-IT-IS's concerning 0.0, suggesting AS-IT-IS may have inadequate serving size information. **Choose AS-IT-IS** if you prioritize budget and trust the brand despite limited nutritional breakdown. **Choose Nutrabay** if you want complete ingredient visibility, digestive support, and don't mind paying 21% more per serving. Both offer perfect transparency scores (10.0), but AS-IT-IS delivers better bang-for-buck for cost-conscious buyers.
AS-IT-IS
6.0/10
AverageTieCost/serving: ₹161.52
Based on MRP. Actual price may be lower.
Form: Powder (Scoop)
Servings: 10
AS-IT-IS Nutrition Whey Protein Concentrate excels in value and transparency but falls short in providing complete dosing information. At ₹161.52 per serving, it is a budget-friendly option lacking precise protein content details.
Nutrabay
5.7/10
AverageTieCost/serving: ₹107.37
Cost/Gram Protein: ₹1.49/g protein
Based on MRP. Actual price may be lower.
Form: Powder (Scoop)
Servings: 27
Nutrabay Pure 100% Whey Protein Concentrate offers excellent transparency but falls short in protein content. Its cost per serving is competitive, but consumers seeking higher protein levels might need alternatives.
Scroll right to compare all products →
| Metric | AS-IT-IS Nutrition Whey Protein Concentrate | Nutrabay Pure 100% Whey Protein Concentrate | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall | ✓ 6.0 | 5.7 | AS-IT-IS Nutrition Whey Protein Concentrate |
| Formula | ✓ 7.5 | 2.8 | AS-IT-IS Nutrition Whey Protein Concentrate |
| Dosing | 0.0 | ✓ 6.0 | Nutrabay Pure 100% Whey Protein Concentrate |
| Value | ✓ 8.6 | 5.3 | AS-IT-IS Nutrition Whey Protein Concentrate |
| Transparency | ✓ 10.0 | ✓ 10.0 | Tie |
| Cost/Serving | ₹161.52 | ✓ ₹107.37 | Nutrabay Pure 100% Whey Protein Concentrate |
| Cost/Gram Protein | — | ✓ ₹1.49/g protein | Nutrabay Pure 100% Whey Protein Concentrate |
• AS-IT-IS Nutrition Whey Protein Concentrate costs ₹161.52 per serving vs Nutrabay Pure 100% Whey Protein Concentrate at ₹107.37 — AS-IT-IS Nutrition Whey Protein Concentrate is 50% more expensive (Nutrabay Pure 100% Whey Protein Concentrate is 50% cheaper).
• AS-IT-IS Nutrition Whey Protein Concentrate MRP: ₹1599 for 10 servings vs Nutrabay Pure 100% Whey Protein Concentrate MRP: ₹4099 for 27 servings.
• Formula: AS-IT-IS Nutrition Whey Protein Concentrate scores 7.5 vs Nutrabay Pure 100% Whey Protein Concentrate's 2.8 — AS-IT-IS Nutrition Whey Protein Concentrate has a stronger ingredient formula.
• Dosing: Nutrabay Pure 100% Whey Protein Concentrate scores 6.0 vs AS-IT-IS Nutrition Whey Protein Concentrate's 0.0 — Nutrabay Pure 100% Whey Protein Concentrate hits clinical dose benchmarks more accurately.
• Value: AS-IT-IS Nutrition Whey Protein Concentrate scores 8.6 vs Nutrabay Pure 100% Whey Protein Concentrate's 5.3 — AS-IT-IS Nutrition Whey Protein Concentrate offers better value per serving.
| Shared ingredient | AS-IT-IS Nutrition Whey Protein Concentrate | Nutrabay Pure 100% Whey Protein Concentrate |
|---|---|---|
| BCAAs | 21 g | 16.0833 g |
Only in AS-IT-IS Nutrition Whey Protein Concentrate
Only in Nutrabay Pure 100% Whey Protein Concentrate
| Metric | AS-IT-IS Nutrition Whey Protein Concentrate | Nutrabay Pure 100% Whey Protein Concentrate |
|---|---|---|
| MRP | ₹1599 | ₹4099 |
| Cost/Serving | ₹161.52 | ₹107.37 |
Based on MRP. Actual price may be lower. | ||
| Servings/Pack | 10 | 27 |
| Cost per gram protein | Not available | Not available |
Compare more products in this category from the full ranking hub.
Other head-to-head matchups featuring these products
Amino Spiking in India: We Analyzed 218 Protein Products
Our analysis of 218 Indian protein supplements revealed shocking amino spiking patterns. Learn how to identify amino-spiked products and find truly clean protein.
Protein
Casein vs Whey: What Actually Matters (2026)
Casein and whey both come from milk, but they behave differently in your body. Whey digests fast and triggers a strong muscle-building signal; casein digests slowly and keeps amino acids trickling in for hours. For most Indian users, understanding which one you actually need can save money and simplify your routine.
Protein
Whey Protein Side Effects: Myths vs Reality (2026)
Whey protein is one of the most studied supplements available, yet myths about kidney damage, acne, and toxicity persist—especially in India. This guide separates verified side effects from exaggerated fears, helping you make an informed decision based on your health profile, dose, and product quality.
Protein
3 min read · Last updated: 8 Mar 2026